Your investor has agreed to the cash. Your company secretary asks a question that stops the room: are we doing a private placement, a preferential allotment, or a convertible note? Each route has its own approvals, valuation rules, and timelines under the Companies Act, 2013. Get the route wrong, and you could face penalties, refunds, or a messy conversion down the line. This guide compares convertible note vs private placement vs preferential allotment from a compliance perspective. You’ll see how the three overlap, what each one needs, and which suits your round, with a side-by-side table. Let’s take it apart.
Quick answer: A private placement is the sale of securities to a limited number of people under Section 42. A preferential allotment is an issue of shares to selected persons at the price determined by a registered valuer under Section 62(1)(c), and it has to be made under Section 42 also. A convertible note is a debt-first instrument that converts to equity under Section 62(3).
Table of Contents
First, Clear Up a Common Misunderstanding
Often, founders consider private placement and preferential allotment as competing options. They apply jointly for the most priced startup rounds. Also, preferential allotment should meet the conditions of private placement under Section 42, as provided under Rule 13(1) of the Companies (Share Capital and Debentures) Rules, 2014.
Look at it like this:
- Preferential allotment clarifies what you are issuing, to whom, and at what price.
- Private placement tells you how to make the offer, how to handle the money, and how to report it.
- Convertible notes sit outside this chain in the first place because the money comes in as debt. When the note converts, the share issue rules apply.
Private Placement: The Section 42 Rules
The process has been prescribed under Section 42 of the Companies Act, 2013, and Rule 14 of the Companies (Prospectus and Allotment of Securities) Rules, 2014. The main requirements are:
- Special resolution of the shareholders before the offer.
- Offer letter in Form PAS-4, addressed only by name to identified persons.
- Not more than 200 persons to whom securities are offered in a financial year, excluding qualified institutional buyers and employees under an ESOP scheme.
- Money through banking channels into a separate bank account, never cash.
- Allotment within 60 days of receipt of money. Otherwise, refund within the next 15 days or pay 12% annual interest.
- No use of the money until allotment is made and return of allotment is filed.
- Form PAS-3 to be filed with the Registrar within 15 days from the date of allotment along with the list of allottees.
Preferential Allotment: Valuation and the 12-Month Window
Section 62(1)(c) preferential allotment introduces price and timing controls to Section 42:
- Check first your Articles of Association, as they must permit it.
- Special resolution with a detailed explanatory statement giving the details of the proposed allottees and their post-issue holding.
- Report of a registered valuer for an unlisted company. The price at which the issue is made cannot be less than the price stated in that report.
- 12-month period. The allotment must be made within 12 months of the special resolution. After that, you need a new resolution.
- For instruments like CCPS that are convertible, the conversion price or formula must be fixed in advance based on the valuation.
The price rule is inflexible. In a case note in the ICSI journal from June 2026, it refers to a company where its registered valuer had determined a fair value of ₹334.59 per share. The company allotted at ₹334, rounding off the paise. Even then, the Registrar held it to be a violation and imposed a penalty. Obtain a true valuation report and price at or above it.
Convertible Note: The Debt-First Route
A 2026 PIB document on startup provisions under the Companies Act confirms that startups can receive ₹25 lakh or more by way of convertible note in a single tranche from a person, which is convertible or repayable within a period of 10 years and which will not be treated as a deposit. The compliance chain is something like this:
- DPIIT startup certificate on the date of issuance: ₹25 lakh or more per investor in a single tranche.
- Special resolution under Section 62(3) approving the terms of conversion before raising the money, followed by Form MGT-14.
- Form CN for foreign investors, through the bank, within 30 days from issuance.
- On conversion: Form PAS-3 (also Form FC-GPR for foreign holders) and board allotment.
The conversion terms were pre-approved, so a domestic note can convert to equity without the full preferential allotment process. Some practitioners say the Section 42 offer rules should still apply to the issue of notes, so get your company secretary to check which way your documents go.
Convertible Note vs Private Placement vs Preferential Allotment: Compliance Table
| Factor | Private placement (Section 42) | Preferential allotment (Section 62(1)(c) + Section 42) | Convertible note (deposit rules + Section 62(3)) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who can use it? | Any company | Any company with authorising articles | DPIIT-registered startups only |
| Shareholder approval | Special resolution | Special resolution with a detailed explanatory statement | Special resolution before money is raised |
| Valuation report | Needed when combined with a preferential issue | Mandatory for unlisted companies | Not needed at conversion for domestic notes when pre-approved |
| Investor limit | Up to 200 persons per financial year | Same, through Section 42 | No numeric limit, but ₹25 lakh minimum per investor per tranche |
| Money handling | Separate bank account | Separate bank account | Received as debt |
| Allotment deadline | 60 days from receipt of money | 60 days from money, and within 12 months of the resolution | Conversion within ten years of issue |
| Use of funds | Only after allotment and PAS-3 | Only after allotment and PAS-3 | Usable as per the note terms |
| Main ROC filings | MGT-14, PAS-3 within 15 days | MGT-14, PAS-3 within 15 days | MGT-14 at issue, PAS-3 on conversion |
| Foreign investor reporting | FC-GPR within 30 days of allotment | FC-GPR within 30 days of allotment | Form CN at issue, FC-GPR on conversion |
Which Route Fits Your Round?
Use these common scenarios to answer the convertible note vs private placement vs preferential allotment question for your own round.
- Priced seed or Series A round with a fund: Preferential allotment of equity or CCPS through the Section 42 process.
- Fast angel round where valuation is not clear: Convertible note, if you have the DPIIT certificate and each ticket is ₹25 lakh or more.
- Small tickets (< ₹25 lakh) or no DPIIT certificate: Preferential allotment of CCPS or CCDs, usually on iSAFE-style terms.
- Only from existing shareholders, in proportion to holdings: Consider a rights issue, which has a lighter process.
Compliance Mistakes That Trigger Penalties
- PAS-3 late filing: The 15-day clock begins at allotment, not at closing.
- Pricing below the price of the registered valuer, even by a rupee.
- Utilisation of investors’ money before filing PAS-3.
- Passing the Section 62(3) resolution after the convertible note cash arrives.
- Letting the 12-month preferential window expire without a new resolution.
It helps to keep a filing calendar for each round. The Startup Gig offers MCA compliance support for these forms and deadlines.
Private Placement or Convertible Note? Structure Your Deal Safely.
Contact Our Legal TeamQuick Recap
- Preferential allotment and private placement usually go hand in hand in a priced round.
- Private placement determines the offer process: PAS-4, separate account, 60 days allotment, PAS-3 within 15 days.
- Preferential allotment has a registered valuer’s price floor and a 12-month window.
- Convertible notes require DPIIT status, a ₹25 lakh ticket, and a Section 62(3) resolution before cash comes in.
- Most penalties occur for late filing, pricing below the valuer, and early use of funds.
Final Thoughts
The decision between a convertible note, private placement, or preferential allotment is more about getting the chain of approvals right than choosing a tag. Priced rounds generally combine preferential allotment and private placement provisions. Convertible notes take a different path at issue but follow the same filing system on conversion. Determine the path before the term sheet is signed and not after the money comes in. If you’re planning a round, The Startup Gig’s fundraising advisory for founders can help you pick the route and handle the compliance.
Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and is not intended as and should not be taken as legal or tax advice. Rules and deadlines may vary, so you should consult a qualified company secretary, lawyer, or chartered accountant before issuing securities.
Close Your Funding Round Without Risking ROC Penalties
Explore Our Compliance SupportFrequently Asked Questions
Does a private company need a special resolution for a private placement?
Yes. Rule 14 mandates shareholder approval by special resolution for a private placement prior to the offer being made. Then the resolution has to be filed with the Registrar in Form MGT-14. If you skip this step, the whole offer may be non-compliant.
Can I issue preferential shares slightly below the valuer’s price?
Negative. The price of issue shall be equal to or more than the price in the registered valuer’s report. A company has been penalised by a Registrar for rounding down ₹334.59 to ₹334, so always round up and check the final figure before allotment.
Is a valuation report needed for a rights issue?
A rights issue offered to existing shareholders in proportion to their shareholdings does not require a report from a registered valuer under the Companies Act. If any shares are being issued to non-resident shareholders, you may still need a valuation for FEMA pricing purposes, so check before you issue.
What happens if the 12-month preferential allotment window lapses?
The original special resolution cannot be used anymore. The company has to pass a fresh special resolution with an updated explanatory statement before the allotment is completed. If the valuation is dated, a new valuation report may be required.
Can a convertible note convert into preference shares?
Generally no. Section 62(3) provides for conversion of a loan that contains an option to convert the same into equity shares, which is pre-approved. If investors are interested in preference shares, structure the instrument as CCPS from day one by preferential allotment.