All shook hands, and the term sheet was signed. And then a 60-page Shareholders Agreement lands in your inbox, drafted by the investor’s law firm, full of clauses you’ve never discussed. At this point, founders often feel outgunned. The investor’s lawyers do this weekly; you might do it biannually. You can still hold your own. Negotiating with investors’ lawyers is largely a matter of preparation, structure, and knowing which battles matter. This guide covers who those lawyers really work for, how to prepare, how to run the negotiation, which clauses need the most care, and how to keep costs under control. Let’s break it down.
Short answer: To negotiate well with an investor’s legal team:
- Get your own startup lawyer early.
- Prepare disclosures early and tidy up records.
- Separate commercial points from legal drafting points.
- Send a single, short list of issues instead of disorganised emails.
- Trade concessions, not handouts.
- Take business disputes to the investor partner, not to the lawyers.
Understand Who the Investor’s Lawyer Works For
The investor’s lawyer represents the fund, not you, and not the deal. Their job is to protect their client’s money and keep the risk to it low. First drafts will probably be investor-friendly. It is natural, not hostile.
In India, this is controlled by two rules:
- They negotiate through your attorney. Under the Bar Council of India Rules (Part VI), available on India Code, an advocate should not negotiate directly with the opposite party except through that party’s advocate. Once you have counsel, the drafting discussions should be between lawyers.
- One firm cannot fairly represent both sides. The same rules prevent advocates from representing conflicting parties in the same matter. Never agree to “share” the investor’s lawyer just to save money. The Startup Gig’s fundraising advisory for founders follows this principle and advises founders or investors, but never both sides of the same deal.
What Your Own Lawyer Should Do
Your lawyer’s job is to translate legal drafts into business consequences that you can decide on. When talking with the lawyers of the investors through your counsel, ask for a short note after every draft: what has changed, what it means for founders, and whether to accept, counter, or reject each point. That note allows you to keep control of the decisions while the lawyers take care of the wording.
Prepare Before the First Draft Arrives
Much of your power to negotiate comes from work done before the first drafts fly.
Fix Problems Before Diligence Finds Them
Every gap the investor’s lawyers find becomes a new warranty, indemnity, or condition precedent. Conduct your own legal due diligence review of the company. Fix missing ROC filings, unsigned IP assignments, and undocumented option promises.
Know Your Priorities
Be sure to identify your three to five top issues before reading the draft. Common ones are founder liability, board control, vesting terms, and the reserved matters list. Everything else is a chip to be swapped.
Agree on the Process Upfront
Apply the term sheet stage to remedy 3 process points:
- Who writes the definitive contract. The drafting party has the starting text. Check with your counsel if they can do the first draft.
- A cap on the investor’s legal fees if the company is paying.
- A target schedule for drafts, comments, and signing.
How to Negotiate With Investors’ Lawyers on the SHA and SSA
Separate Commercial Points From Legal Points
Commercial points are business decisions: valuation, board seats, vesting, and veto thresholds. The legal points are about drafting. How do you draft warranties, how do you cap indemnity, and what is “cause”? You discuss commercial terms with the investor partner. Let lawyers do the drafting. Mixing the two drags out each call.
Respond With a Single-Issue List
Have counsel review a draft and send one consolidated issues list. Each line should include the clause, your concern, your suggested change, and a short reason. This makes the negotiation orderly and easy for the other side to accept points in bulk.
Ask “Why” and Offer Alternatives
If a clause sounds too harsh, ask what risk it is meant to cover. The investor’s concern is usually narrow. A narrower scope clause solves it. Non-solicitation and confidentiality terms are often used in lieu of a founder-wide non-compete.
Trade, Do Not Concede
Don’t give away a point for nothing. Link concessions: “We accept the information rights as drafted subject to the cap on the indemnity being reduced to the investment amount.” Keep a running list of what each side has conceded.
Escalate Business Disputes to the Partner
If lawyers are hung up on a point that is really commercial, stop and raise it with the investing partner. The partners want the deal and the relationship. Lawyers are paid to reduce risk.
Clauses Where Investor Counsel Pushes Hardest
| Clause | Typical investor-side draft | Reasonable founder response |
|---|---|---|
| Representations and warranties | Founders give warranties personally, with few limits. | Limit founder warranties to title, authority and a few basics; add “to the best of knowledge” qualifiers. |
| Indemnity | Unlimited, long-lasting liability | Cap at the investment amount or lower, set time limits and a minimum claim threshold |
| Disclosure letter | Narrow disclosures only | Disclose every known issue against the warranties so they are carved out. |
| Events of default | Broad triggers with harsh remedies | Narrow to fraud, wilful breach and material uncured breaches |
| Founder non-compete | Long post-exit restriction | Limit to the period of employment, plus non-solicitation and confidentiality. |
| Information rights | Weekly or ad hoc reporting | Monthly or quarterly MIS and annual audited accounts |
Some of these points are shaped by Indian law. You negotiate limits, time frames, and procedures. The Indian Contract Act, 1872, defines a Contract of Indemnity. Section 27 of the same Act declares agreements in restraint of trade to be void. This is why post-exit non-competes are difficult to enforce in India.
Managing Time and Legal Costs
Long-form negotiations get costly when they drift. Wrap them snugly:
- Agree turnaround times for each draft, for example, three to five working days.
- Use a single master document with change tracking and version numbers clearly visible.
- Arrange calls with all parties to close open points, rather than long email chains.
- Leave the small wording issues until the big issues are taken care of.
- Verify legal invoices against the fee cap agreed in the term sheet.
Mistakes Founders Make
- Negotiating without their own lawyer to save fees and then signing broad personal warranties.
- Re-opening agreed commercial terms at the long-form stage, which damages trust.
- Fighting every clause equally and hiding what matters most.
- Hiding known problems rather than disclosing them, which later become indemnity claims.
- Letting exclusivity expire without a plan, losing leverage with other investors.
Level the Playing Field Against Investor Law Firms
Discover Our Fundraising AdvisoryQuick Recap
- The investor’s lawyer defends the fund, so expect investor-friendly drafts and react calmly.
- Get your own lawyer early, and never use the investor’s lawyer.
- Clean up records; provide a full disclosure letter before diligence.
- Send one list of issues, trade concessions, and escalate commercial issues to the partner.
- Limit founder warranties, cap indemnifications, and narrow default events.
Final Thoughts
You don’t need to outlast the investor’s lawyers. You need your own lawyer, clean records, clear priorities, and a process. Founders often find that calm, organised negotiation with investors’ lawyers leads to faster closing, fairer terms, and a better relationship with new investors. Next steps: Prioritise your issues, do your own diligence, and agree on the drafting process before you get the first draft. If you want a founder-side team for your round, The Startup Gig can support you from term sheet to closing.
Disclaimer: This article is for general information purposes and is not legal advice. Each deal is different, so you should consult a qualified startup lawyer before signing any transaction documents.
Have an Investor Draft in Your Inbox? Let’s Review It Together.
Contact Us TodayFrequently Asked Questions
Can I talk to the investor directly during legal negotiations?
Yes. Founders and investing partners can and should discuss commercial points directly. Just keep drafting discussions between the lawyers, and confirm any business agreement in writing to both legal teams so it appears correctly in the next draft.
Should my lawyer or the investor’s lawyer draft the SHA?
Both can, but the drafting side has control of the starting text and framing of every clause. The lead investor’s counsel drafts in many Indian rounds. If you have the clout, have your counsel draft the first draft.
What is a disclosure letter?
A disclosure letter details any known exceptions to the warranties you provide, such as an ongoing dispute or a late filing. Generally, matters that are properly disclosed cannot form the basis for a subsequent warranty claim. So, be sure to describe each issue fully and clearly, not vaguely.
Can founders refuse to give personal warranties?
You can push back, and many investors are willing to give limited founder warranties covering the basics such as share ownership and authority. The company typically offers a business warranty. Founders that do provide broader warranties should negotiate low caps and short claim periods.
How many rounds of drafts are normal for an SHA?
Most deals go through a couple of rounds of comments before signing. That number depends on the starting distance between parties and how organised the process is. The back-and-forth is generally reduced by having a single issues list per round and regular calls.