Shareholders’ Agreement vs Term Sheet vs SSA: What Each Document Does

The first priced round brings with it a stack of legal documents with similar-sounding names. The first thing was the term sheet, and now we are simultaneously drafting a Share Subscription Agreement and a Shareholders’ Agreement. Who is running what? Which ones bind you? Founders who understand shareholders’ agreement vs. term sheet vs. SSA negotiate better and avoid surprises after closing. This guide covers what each document does, how they relate to each other, why your Articles of Association are important, and how stamp duty impacts enforceability in India. Let’s break it down.

Short answer: The term sheet is a short, largely non-binding outline of the deal. The SSA (Share Subscription Agreement) is the contract obliging the investor to subscribe for new shares and the company to issue them. The Shareholders’ Agreement (SHA) is the binding rulebook for the shareholders’ relationship after the investment.

 

The Term Sheet: The Deal Outline

In a few pages, the term sheet sets out the main commercial terms: valuation, amount, instrument, board seats, investor rights, and conditions. It’s the template for the long-form documents.

Most of its commercial terms are not legally binding. There are usually a few clauses that bind on signing, such as confidentiality, exclusivity, costs, and governing law. Its practical weight is much larger than its legal weight because it damages trust to reopen agreed terms later.

 

The SSA: The Subscription Contract

The Share Subscription Agreement relates to the actual investment transaction. It is signed by the company, the investors, and generally the founders. The main contents are as follows:

  • Subscription details: number and type of shares, price, and amount
  • Conditions precedent: things the company must do before the investor pays
  • Representations and warranties: statements regarding the company’s legal and financial status
  • Closing mechanics: what every party contributes at the closing table
  • Indemnity: compensation for breach of warranty. It is a type of contract as defined u/s 124 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.
  • Termination: what happens if closing does not occur by the long-stop date

Most SSA obligations end with the issuance of the shares. The usual intention is that warranty, indemnity, and confidentiality clauses survive closing for an agreed period.

 

The Shareholders’ Agreement: The Rulebook for the Relationship

The Shareholders’ Agreement regulates the management of the company and the transfer of shares after the investment. The company, the founders, investors, and usually all of the existing shareholders sign it. It usually includes:

  • Board structure and directors nominated
  • Reserved matters requiring investor consent
  • Information and inspection rights
  • Founder vesting, lock-in, and leaver clauses
  • Restrictions on transfers: right of first refusal, tag-along, and drag-along
  • Pre-emption and anti-dilution rights
  • Exit rights and deadlines
  • Dispute resolution, usually arbitration

The SHA, unlike the SSA, is in effect for as long as the investor holds shares, until an IPO, or until a superseding SHA is negotiated in a subsequent round.

 

Shareholders’ Agreement vs Term Sheet vs SSA: Side-by-Side

Factor Term sheet Share Subscription Agreement (SSA) Shareholders’ Agreement (SHA)
Purpose Agree on the deal outline Complete the investment transaction Govern the ongoing relationship
Timing Before diligence Signed before closing Signed with the SSA, effective from closing
Legally binding? Mostly no, except a few clauses Yes Yes
Typical length 2 to 10 pages 20 to 50 pages 30 to 80 pages
Main contents Valuation, rights in outline Conditions precedent, warranties, closing, indemnity Board, vetoes, transfers, exits, disputes
Lifespan Until long-form documents are signed Mostly ends at closing Continues while investors hold shares
Mirrored in Articles? No No Yes, the main rights must be

The number of pages can vary greatly from one deal to the next. Use them as a very rough guide only.

 

The Fourth Document Founders Forget: Articles of Association

Your Articles of Association (AoA) are the company’s constitution. The memorandum and articles bind the company and its members as if each member had signed the same under Section 10 of the Companies Act, 2013.

This is important for the SHA. In V.B. Rangaraj v. V.B. Gopalakrishnan (1992), the Supreme Court held that a restriction on the transfer of shares agreed between the shareholders but not incorporated in the Articles did not bind the company or its shareholders. While subsequent decisions have softened this view in some ways, the safe course is still clear. Investors insist their primary SHA rights are inserted into the articles at closing.

Here’s what that means for your round:

  • The SHA’s governance and transfer clauses are also reflected in the company’s amended articles.
  • The shareholders adopt a special resolution amending the Articles of Association.
  • The company files the resolution with the Registrar in Form MGT-14.
  • If the SHA and articles conflict, the articles usually prevail. So check that they are consistent.

The Startup Gig’s MCA compliance support includes amendment of Articles and associated filings.

 

Stamp Duty and Execution

SSAs and SHAs must be stamped under the stamp law of the state concerned. Rates and methods differ state by state. E-stamping is common now.

What if you don’t stamp? In a ruling in December 2023, the Supreme Court held that an unstamped or insufficiently stamped agreement is not void, but inadmissible in evidence until the duty and penalty, if any, are paid. The defect can be fixed, but you can’t use the document in court until it is fixed. Stamp before or at signing to avoid delay in case of dispute.

A few execution points help as well:

  • Execute the SSA and SHA together, with the SHA effective upon closing.
  • Get the current shareholders who have to be bound and all the necessary people to sign.
  • Any future shareholder shall be bound to sign a deed of adherence to the SHA.

 

How the Three Documents Flow in a Round

  1. Term sheet signed: Start of the exclusivity and confidentiality period.
  2. Due diligence: The investor checks your records. This stage will be shorter if you do a legal due diligence review beforehand.
  3. Drafting: SSA and SHA are drafted and negotiated in parallel.
  4. Signatures: SSA and SHA signed and stamped.
  5. Amended articles: Conditions precedent fulfilled.
  6. Closing: Cash received, shares issued, filings done.
  7. Post-closing: The SHA is the rulebook from here on in.

 

Common Mix-Ups Founders Make

When the distinction between the shareholders’ agreement vs term sheet vs SSA gets blurred, founders make avoidable mistakes:

  • Treating the term sheet as final. SHA clauses often come in new flavours. Read the long-form drafts as closely as the term sheet.
  • Disregarding SSA warranties. They create a real liability if a statement made about the company is untrue.
  • Forgetting the Articles. An SHA right that never makes it into the Articles is difficult to enforce against the company.
  • Excluding existing shareholders. Shares of an early angel who does not sign the SHA may not be subject to transfer and drag-along rights.
Discover Our Startup Legal Services

Quick Recap

  • The term sheet sets out the deal and is mostly non-binding.
  • The SSA is the binding contract for the share purchase and typically expires at closing.
  • The SHA is the long-term and binding rulebook for shareholders.
  • The key SHA rights need to be set out in the Articles of Association to bind the company.
  • Stamp agreements correctly. Unstamped agreements cannot be received in evidence until the duty is paid.

 

Final Thoughts

The question of shareholders’ agreement vs. term sheet vs. SSA is really a matter of sequence and purpose. The term sheet sets the direction, the SSA closes the investment, and the SHA, with your articles, governs everything after that. Knowing which document does what allows you to focus negotiations where it matters and keep your round legally sound. Next steps: Before you sign, ask your lawyer to give you a summary of how your rights will be reflected in the Articles. If you’re getting ready for a round, The Startup Gig’s fundraising advisory for founders includes all three documents.

Disclaimer: This article is intended for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Laws, stamp rates, and court positions may change. Seek advice from a qualified lawyer before signing investment documents.

Ready to Close Your Priced Round Cleanly? Let’s Talk.

Contact Us Today

Frequently Asked Questions

Can the SSA and SHA be combined into one document?

Yes. Some smaller rounds use one share subscription and shareholders’ agreement. It saves time on drafting, but separating the documents means that transaction terms are not mixed up with long-term governance, which makes later rounds easier to manage and amend.

What happens to the old SHA when a new round closes?

Normally, all shareholders sign an amended and restated SHA which supersedes the old one. It creates new rights for investors and updates existing terms. The Articles of Association are again amended to reflect the restated agreement.

How does a new shareholder become bound by the SHA?

New shareholders are normally asked to sign a deed of adherence agreeing to be bound by the existing SHA as if they were an original party. Most SHAs require signing this deed as a condition of any share transfer, so incoming holders cannot simply opt out of the agreed terms.

Who needs to sign the Shareholders’ Agreement?

The company signs it. The founders sign it. The investors sign it. Existing shareholders, such as angels or early employees who hold shares, often sign too, so that transfer restrictions and drag-along rights apply to everyone whose shares are covered.

How long does a shareholders’ agreement stay in force?

It typically lasts until some termination event specified in the agreement. Typical triggers are an IPO, all investors exiting, or a new round replacing it. Some clauses, such as confidentiality, may survive termination for a period agreed upon.